Comments on: A Totally Safe And Completely Organic Way To Clean Up The Oil In The Gulf Of Mexico http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico Raising Awareness And Providing Practical Ways That We All Can Help Save The Environment Thu, 10 May 2012 14:54:11 +0000 hourly 1 By: Max http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-129 Max Wed, 19 May 2010 13:28:20 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-129 You can't prevent stuff like this from happening, if the possible loss of more than a few billion dollars doesn't persuade companies to be more careful, no kind of law will. The only thing you can hope for, is that they will learn from it. You can't built stations, ships and other kind of device 100 % safe, there is bound to be a problem sooner or later (just the magnitude of the problem changes). However, one could think about measures to REDUCE the magnitude of a problem. You can’t prevent stuff like this from happening, if the possible loss of more than a few billion dollars doesn’t persuade companies to be more careful, no kind of law will.

The only thing you can hope for, is that they will learn from it. You can’t built stations, ships and other kind of device 100 % safe, there is bound to be a problem sooner or later (just the magnitude of the problem changes). However, one could think about measures to REDUCE the magnitude of a problem.

]]> By: Krusty http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-112 Krusty Tue, 11 May 2010 18:28:55 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-112 Also pontoons of the same material were linked together and surrounded the spill or made a barrier that kept it from shore. Also pontoons of the same material were linked together and surrounded the spill or made a barrier that kept it from shore.

]]> By: Krusty http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-111 Krusty Tue, 11 May 2010 18:26:38 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-111 I remember a friend of my fathers years ago made pads that looked a lot like scotch brights, they would be dropped into an oil slick and absorb most of the oil. They would then be moved to a ship or shore and be squeezed out between rollers and reused. When he approached oil companies they were not interested because the government of where the spill was took care of it. I remember a friend of my fathers years ago made pads that looked a lot like scotch brights, they would be dropped
into an oil slick and absorb most of the oil. They would then be moved to a ship or shore and be squeezed out between
rollers and reused. When he approached oil companies they were not interested because the government of where the spill
was took care of it.

]]> By: Dave http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-110 Dave Tue, 11 May 2010 16:24:22 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-110 Hey Russ, these are all great ?'s, but did you actually watch the video? It may not be the ultimate solution, I don't know how convinced I am either, but if you actually watched the video you'd see it does a whole heckuva lot more than NOTHING. Right now, time is the biggest problem and while a long-term solution is needed to fix this disaster, a logistical nightmare sounds pretty damn good compared to waiting for the "perfect plan" while the effects of the oil spill become a REAL nightmare. Hey Russ, these are all great ?’s, but did you actually watch the video? It may not be the ultimate solution, I don’t know how convinced I am either, but if you actually watched the video you’d see it does a whole heckuva lot more than NOTHING. Right now, time is the biggest problem and while a long-term solution is needed to fix this disaster, a logistical nightmare sounds pretty damn good compared to waiting for the “perfect plan” while the effects of the oil spill become a REAL nightmare.

]]> By: bri http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-109 bri Tue, 11 May 2010 14:21:04 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-109 did you WATCH the video? they posed many possibilities, though none tested that i know of, it at least poses a starting-off point for a potential use.. the hay could be burned by a biowaste facility or a company that uses wood chips to make energy, they already have the filters in place to get the gunk out of the smoke. did you WATCH the video? they posed many possibilities, though none tested that i know of, it at least poses a starting-off point for a potential use.. the hay could be burned by a biowaste facility or a company that uses wood chips to make energy, they already have the filters in place to get the gunk out of the smoke.

]]> By: Hank t http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-108 Hank t Tue, 11 May 2010 14:03:39 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-108 Fantastic idea!! The gulf states should mobilize farmers, citizens and idle fisherman to implement this strategy. Awesome!! Fantastic idea!! The gulf states should mobilize farmers, citizens and idle fisherman to implement this strategy. Awesome!!

]]> By: German guy http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-107 German guy Tue, 11 May 2010 11:40:11 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-107 Well, first of all: I am pretty sure that the crude oil in the Gulf has a very different consistency than the refined oil which they used for their experiment from the canister. Crude oil should be much thicker! Secondly, hay doesn't really soak up the oil, it merely sticks together with the oil. Only real hair or some man-made fibres could possibly do the job and soak up a small part of the oil. And lastly, I agree with every question that Russ Rogers asked. Alas, I think that it cannot be done. It is impossible to obtain and to transport so much hay or hair or fibre or whatever to the Gulf and to spread it onto the oil, then fish it all out again and transport it to - where? You can be sure that the best experts from all over the world are already involved, but now that BP officially asks the population for any suggestions and new ideas, you can imagine how bad the situation and their despair really is... Ever since the 20th century, we are treating our planet so badly, that ultimately we will have to pay the price. I really hope that there will be a solution coming up shortly to get this damned containment box attached to the leak. The disaster gets worse and worse with every minute. Best wishes to you from Germany! Well, first of all:
I am pretty sure that the crude oil in the Gulf has a very different consistency than the refined oil which they used for their experiment from the canister. Crude oil should be much thicker!

Secondly, hay doesn’t really soak up the oil, it merely sticks together with the oil. Only real hair or some man-made fibres could possibly do the job and soak up a small part of the oil.

And lastly, I agree with every question that Russ Rogers asked. Alas, I think that it cannot be done. It is impossible to obtain and to transport so much hay or hair or fibre or whatever to the Gulf and to spread it onto the oil, then fish it all out again and transport it to – where?

You can be sure that the best experts from all over the world are already involved, but now that BP officially asks the population for any suggestions and new ideas, you can imagine how bad the situation and their despair really is…

Ever since the 20th century, we are treating our planet so badly, that ultimately we will have to pay the price.

I really hope that there will be a solution coming up shortly to get this damned containment box attached to the leak. The disaster gets worse and worse with every minute.

Best wishes to you from Germany!

]]> By: Debbie http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-106 Debbie Tue, 11 May 2010 00:00:30 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-106 I have posted this on my FaceBook wall a few times, and I hope everyone spreads this ingenious cleanup idea all over the internet. Thank you for posting this article and video. I have posted this on my FaceBook wall a few times, and I hope everyone spreads this ingenious cleanup idea all over the internet.

Thank you for posting this article and video.

]]> By: Colleen Smith http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-104 Colleen Smith Sun, 09 May 2010 16:42:51 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-104 I hope they try this and soon. The hay can be taken care of and it can't hurt to try. I hope they try this and soon. The hay can be taken care of and it can’t hurt to try.

]]> By: Russ Rogers http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-103 Russ Rogers Sat, 08 May 2010 15:58:09 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-103 How much hay do you need to soak up 5,000 barrels of oil a day? Where do you get that much hay? How do you transport that hay to the gulf? What do you do with the oil soaked hay? How do you transport it away from the gulf? Do you bury it? Do you burn it? How much will that cost? Should the hay be spread along the shore line? Should the hay be shipped out to the source of the spill? It's an interesting idea. But it seems like a logistical nightmare. I'm not convinced Hay is the solution to this disaster. How much hay do you need to soak up 5,000 barrels of oil a day? Where do you get that much hay? How do you transport that hay to the gulf? What do you do with the oil soaked hay? How do you transport it away from the gulf? Do you bury it? Do you burn it? How much will that cost?

Should the hay be spread along the shore line? Should the hay be shipped out to the source of the spill?

It’s an interesting idea. But it seems like a logistical nightmare. I’m not convinced Hay is the solution to this disaster.

]]> By: Baric http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-102 Baric Sat, 08 May 2010 15:24:34 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-102 The best way to clean up the Gulf of Mexico, is to prevent it in the future. When something like this happens, there was always some excuse, and the truth is that in fact people are just careless, and companies looking for ways to save as much as possible, and therefore let a semi proper ships in traffic. <a href="http://siberiantiger1.blogspot.com" rel="nofollow">http://siberiantiger1.blogspot.com </a> The best way to clean up the Gulf of Mexico, is to prevent it in the future. When something like this happens, there was always some excuse, and the truth is that in fact people are just careless, and companies looking for ways to save as much as possible, and therefore let a semi proper ships in traffic.

http://siberiantiger1.blogspot.com

]]> By: George McI vor http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/archives/a-totally-safe-and-completely-organic-way-to-clean-up-the-oil-in-the-gulf-of-mexico/comment-page-1#comment-101 George McI vor Sat, 08 May 2010 02:33:57 +0000 http://howtohelpsavetheenvironment.com/?p=91#comment-101 Sometimes the most simple ideas that may work are ignored . Due to the fact that the don't originate from the perceived highly educated strata of society . A suit and tie would probably have convinced 80% of your viewers I am sorry to say. Good work guys it's the only viable solution I have yet to see. Sometimes the most simple ideas that may work are ignored . Due to the fact that the don’t originate from the perceived highly educated strata of society . A suit and tie would probably have convinced 80% of your viewers I am sorry to say. Good work guys it’s the only viable solution I have yet to see.

]]>